atime Blog-atimes atimes

Sovereign Credit Improves: Ultimate Systemic Risk Measure

April 7th, 2009
By
David Goldman

How soon we forget. It really did look like the end of the world out there at the beginning of the year  and gold looked like the only thing worth owning.

Governments can bail out financial institutions, but who will bail out the governments? If the prospective cost of a bailout gets too large, it will take down the relevant government, as in the case of Iceland. In February the British press ran headlines like “Reykjavik-on-Thames.” Bank deposits as a proportion of GDP are far higher in the UK than in the US, and protection on the British sovereign had shot out to LIBOR +160 basis points, higher than Brazil protection was trading less than a year ago.

Sovereign credit depends on bank credit. The prospect of bank nationalization followed by a chain-reaction collapse of the insurance sector threatened to take the sovereigns down with it. That is why it was not in the cards. To the extent that governments toyed with the idea as promoted by academic tinkerers like Krugman and Stiglitz in the US, or the ultimate left-wing social experimenter George Soros, a trip to the brink convinced governments otherwise. I warned about this on January 4.

Now we have Soros complaining that the governments are keeping zombie banks alive. Precisely correct: zombie is as good as it gets. By doing so they keep themselves alive. Call it cannibalism and incest, or corruption: it’s better than two, three many Icelands. This isn’t the stuff of a general economic recovery or a stock market boom. It simply means that the banks are worth something rather than nothing. My best guess for that “something” is north of $4 for Citigroup and perhaps around $10 for Bank of America, but this is clearly guesswork. I have a small position in Citigroup preferreds which I bought at a low dollar price and will do quite nicely if Citi converts them to common at a $3.25 price with a 5% haircut, as announced.

Things have calmed down a bit since then. Protection on the UK is down to +116, and Russia is in more than 300 bps from the wides.The tables below show the biggest changes in industrial as well as developing countries’ 5-year credit default swaps, courtesy of Markit:

Ticker

 

 

CLIP

 

 

Name

 

 

5Y Today>

 

 

Daily Chg (bp)>

 

 

Weekly Chg (bp)>

 

 

28 Day Chg (bp)>

 

 

USGB 9A3AAA Utd Sts Amer 57 -6 0 -40
JAPAN 4B818G Japan 90 0 0 -6
DBR 3AB549 Fed Rep Germany 55 -1 4 -33
UKIN 9A17DE Utd Kdom Gt Britn & Nthn Irlnd 116 -8 4 -39
FRTR 3I68EE French Rep 56 -5 0 -38
ITALY 4AB951 Rep Italy 143 -9 1 -49

 

Ticker

 

 

CLIP

 

 

Name

 

 

Doc Clause

 

 

5Y Today>

 

 

Daily Chg (bp)>

 

 

Weekly Chg (bp)>

 

 

28 Day Chg (bp)>

 

 

CZECH 255AD5 Czech Rep CR 162 -37 -50 -140
REPHUN 489A99 Rep Hungary CR 503 -34 43 -116
EXIM Y05BFB Exim Bank CR 355 -33 -30 -58
RUSSIA 7FB37H Russian Fedn CR 463 -32 -23 -304
MEX 9A18EC Utd Mexican Sts CR 330 -30 -39 -152

2 Responses to “Sovereign Credit Improves: Ultimate Systemic Risk Measure”

  1. fetedeslumieres Says:

    Mr. Goldman

    I had to snicker when you wrote who will bail out the governments. Your column in First Things ( I’m assuming it’s you), which arrived yesterday, seems right on the mark.
    I’ll read it again tonight but my gut reaction is that all economies/political structures are similar to ponzi schemes. Without the next generation there is no one left to tax and all the government and finance schemes will eventually be seen as just smoke and mirrors. It’s not the end of the world just your countries substructure. I appreciate your blogging by the way. We are lucky to live in interesting times.

    Chris

  2. David Goldman Says:

    Fetesdelumieres,
    Yup, that’s me in First Things, and thanks for the kind words. Absent a new generation, our financial system does indeed resemble a Ponzi scheme. Fortunately we do have a new generaiton. It’s just too small. We won’t be utterly destitute, just noticeably poorer, I think.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.